I recently took a big risk and "crossed the aisle" from a construction
I took a big risk on a new career, we weren't a good fit, how do I add that to my resume?
Answers
First, you've shown great stability in prior jobs - so that should not be an issue when talking to employers
Second, I would categorize your current role as "Consultant" and you can list both independent/W-2. The positioning of consultant was to expand your skill experience and business knowledge (new perspective), while still interested in consulting, the culture and role of the W-2 firm was not a fit so working independently.
The real question will be why you left your last role if you intend to get a position that is similar. The potential firm will wonder why you would take a role again and if you would stay and if they can invest in you. Assuming you want to go back, then I would position it as the role of consultant can confirm where you're interest truly lies - but sometimes you need to try new activities to expand your skills or to help confirm where your true strength and interests.
I've explained my venture into the start-up world in a similar way, for people who have taken a risk in their
Lastly, when your resume has a potential issue - then best to use networking to get into a new firm versus straight applications. The more you can explain the promise of what you bring, the less your resume becomes a stumbling block. Also, ask your past colleagues to post references/recommendations on your LinkedIn profile - to show you left on good terms and with well respected work.
Hope this helps and good luck.
Mark